Projects and Progettazione: An alternative to the trashy crafty tat of Christmas!

The construction of learning projects with young children is an area I have been interested in since first visiting the pre-schools of Reggio Emilia several years ago.  At the moment with the advent of Christmas, educational (???) blogs are abundant with festive craft projects for children including fablon snowmen, cotton spool christmas trees and glittery paper stockings.   For me project working offers an alternative to what I call the trashy tat of early years craft fodder!  Harsh I know, but working with projects reveals and illuminates just what young children can do when not tricked to the table of trash.

Working in this way (sometimes known as the project approach) enables the possibility for groups of children to work together exchanging ideas, opinions and constructing learning as a group facilitated by educators whom themselves are part of the group, co-constructing knowledge alongside of the children.  They are a powerful pedagogic approach that encourage the space for deep exploration of a theory or concept and the expression and realisation of ideas of children working as a collaborative group.  They challenge the idea of the learning environment as simply an arena of self chosen, self resourced and accessible materials and resources for children to choose from and provide an alternative to the make and take art and craft activity.

Projects or progettazione(as they are called in Reggio Emilia) are offered to the children and often invite engagement of families.  They are used as an opportunity to share the project and raise the profile of what is possible in early childhood education within the wider community of the school/setting.

Sharing project work in Reggio Emilia - exciting and scary!

A project far from being something that is could instead be considered as something we do, a way of working, and a pedagogical approach.  It is not something that is delivered to the children in a single lesson (with an identified objective) or given to the children over a short period of time in chunks of a topic web but rather could be seen as a space where both knowledge itself as well as the process of the project are considered as emergent and elaborative where learning is built over time.  Projects can be both short and long but will have this pattern of knowledge becoming more complex and more elaborate over time.

Engaging Families in Project Work

A challenge in the beginning of any project is how to involve families as participants in the process of the project formation.  On a recent study exchange to visit pre-schools in Stockholm I became increasingly aware of how projects were chosen based on a criteria  not only of interest to the children but also in the ability of the proposed project for family participation.  There the idea of the summer assignment or summer memory was as a UK teacher reflected upon, an important way for the school/setting/educator to establish a mutual relationship with the families that had at its heart an idea about engaging in and constructing the project together.  It was often a simple invite, to bring something in related to the project concept, for example, something that made a sound (for a project about sound) or something found in nature (for a project about the natural world) but the objects and materials gathered from families were displayed with care in a prominent place, their value clearly communicated and then worked with and upon by the children with the resulting documentation shared back.

Workshops can also be part of the project cycle that sees the participation of parents using the materials that the children are simultaneously exploring and the ideas being formed within the project.  At one of the settings I work at, they recently held a wonderful parent meeting where educators facilitated a workshop for parents to play with and invent new tints of colours (an aspect of their project about transformation).  It was an opportunity for families to involve themselves in the work and the emerging ideas of the children.

Networks and Professional Development

Projects hold the possibility for professional development especially when entered into as a group of schools/settings working together.  The project networks of teachers in Stockholm involved other interested parties from the wider context, for example people in the universities with an interest in the language or material being investigated in the project.  Before launching head long into any project there should be a pre-project phase.  This could be described as a time for finding out about the thematic concepts of the project for ourselves as educators from many different perspectives (not just education), a time of reading and research and of developing the vocabulary and language that will help us to see how the children might construct their knowledge. This pre-project phase is also a time of finding out from the children about their thoughts and first ideas.

Reading around the subject of the project is incredibly important.  In a recent project about photography, the reading from philosophical sources raised issues about the lack of plasticity of photography as a medium of expression and the potential that photography held to create images that were created without intention at all. Reading also helped us to understand the differences between an image and a picture.  This was new knowledge and helped the educator team to re-frame the project and alert us to the possibility of oversimplification of techniques and the creation of unintentional images.

Project Pointers

Here are some brief pointers taken from my 2011 journal in thinking about projects with young children.

  • Documentation should be used to reflect back and analyse the intent with children.  Documentation should not be hidden but used for reflection and discussion with children and as a tool for constructing further active contexts for dialogue.
  • Find a way and a time to decide with children where and how we’ll spend our time together.  Project work requires being part of a group and this needs organising.
  • Consider how a summer assignment/memory could act as a starting point for a project and make it visible and possible for children to continue working with the artefacts collected.  Share this documentation with families.
  • Develop parent workshops to work with the materials of the children, their ideas and their theories.
  • Consider what you want to find out as part of the project, use this as a basis for for your research questions.  A project is akin to a research methodology.
  • Dialogue with families should infect the direction of the project and not just be a one way feedback to families.
  • Alert children to the connection between their ideas, thinking and use of materials in a group context (contagion and borrowing of others competencies).  We must directly activate these important opportunities for reflection and noticing what each other does and how it connects.
  • Make ongoing project work visible – if it is visible we can use it as a visual aid for dialogue and discussion with families and children.
  • Observational work and drawing – it is not a way of making beautiful paintings or drawings but as a way of constructing meaning and looking closely at something.  In projects, drawing is an important technique for playing with and communicating ideas.

It would be really good if people reading this blog could add their ‘project pointers’ and help grow this list of things to think about.  I find it fascinating that people from all over the world are reading and sharing my little blog. We have the opportunity to create a  global multiple perspective on working with projects with children.  This is my English slant on it, so what do projects feel like and look like in Australia, America, Peru or Spain…? – or even in other parts of the UK?

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Projects and Progettazione: An alternative to the trashy crafty tat of Christmas!

  1. Completely agree with your thoughts and inspirations. This way of working and pedagogy is the way forward if we want children to become adults who can think creatively, take risks, communicate and express their ideas confidently. Starting with where the children and families are and their interests and experiences is key if we wish to truly engage both parties. At this time of year we should take time to reflect on the children’s experiences and their current starting point inorder to know how we enhance and support them it appears to me that each year we move further away from doing this . Very interested in your thoughts and ideas keep me posted
    Fiona

    Like

  2. Thank you Fiona for your sentiments. It seems so easy at this time of year NOT to reflect on the children’s and families experiences as we busy ourselves with production lines of cards, calendars and other such stuff. Far from being a bah-humbug, if like you say we reflect more intelligently on what the children bring of themselves, their ideas and ways of constructing meaning we might realise how we betray the incredible intelligences of children by enticing their hands but not their minds in this merriment of cotton wool balls, glitter and sequins!!!!

    Like

  3. This year for Christmas we have taken up the project of feelings in response to a child’s needs to deal with her feelings about her family situation (can’t go into details for obvious reasons). We have just started talking about how Christmas makes us feel – and have drawn self portraits with these feelings. I have placed them on the wall without labeling them – no name no feeling – as we will be returning to them next week to see if we can work out who is who and what the feeling is. Of course on many of them it is going to be hard to work out the emotion as, the drawing is VERY basic, but this is the point – sometimes it IS hard to work out what other people are feeling, and I am hoping that this will be our discussion. Although one can never be certain how the project will turn out.

    I have been talking with my staff about feelings and about different ways of communicating them – if they were colours – would the children be able to decide – do they have temperature – ie if we take a series of stone or items and make them different temperature, would the children be able to label them with a feeling, what about dance and movement?

    We, the staff, are making a puppet show play about Rudolf – one of the songs we are singing – as there are so many feelings crammed into the song – and even though we have talked about the feeling in the song with the children we are wondering if making the song more “real” will help the children understand the song better (I am actually beginning to like the song less and less – I mean the poor Rudolf is only like because he is made popular by Santa – what does that say?). We are hoping that the puppet show will trigger the children to start making their own puppets and acting out some of their own emotions – we can only wait and see.

    Of course the children’s interests will dictate to some extent which path or paths we take, we are keeping our Christmas decorating activities to the afternoons – as part of free play – when we will have several art activities available for them to choose from – but will the children choose these activities – or will they be wanting to explore the world of feelings …

    the camera is ready, my notebook too! Can’t wait to hear and see their responses…

    Then of course – after Christmas – we will be able to talk with them again – did Christmas feel like they said – or did it make them feel different than expected? having the documentation written down, that we can share with the children, reminding them what they said before, is fantastic – they are ALWAYS so proud to be quoted – even when they shake their head saying they have changed their mind, that’s not how they think anymore – coming up with a great explanation as to why they said that before – totally logically in their heads – and I can see their logic when I don’t let my adult brain get in the way.

    But, i have the parents to thank for this. IF I did not have a close relationship with the parents – I would never have had the chance to hear about how life is at home for all of “my” children – and it is SO important that the preschool and the home work together to create MEANINGFUL experiences for the children.

    Like

  4. Fantastic Suzanne. You show here in your comment how it is possible to ‘do Christmas’ but in a wonderful way that enables deep thinking and reflection. It has all the excitement of Christmas yet holds true to the competencies of children. Thankyou so much for sharing and I hope it inspires us all to think how Christmas can be explored with young children.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s